2012-Nate Sphon, Berkley Hills Renegades, Baseball

2011-Andy Smithmyer, Delweld, Baseball

2009-Drew Shaulis, Delweld, Baseball and Josh Seidel, Bishop McCort, Football

2008-Tom Burkett, Delweld, Baseball and Eric Lowry, Bishop McCort, Football

2007-Marco Pecora, Richland, Football

2006-Scott Lewis, Bishop McCort, Football
2005-Doug McNulty, Johnstown Grays, Baseball
2004-Steve Slatcoff, Johnstown Grays, Baseball
2003-LaRod Stephens, Greater Johnstown, Football
2002-Jeff Schellhammer, Greater Johnstown, Football
2001-Anthony Zambotti, Galliker Dairy, Baseball
2000-Anthony Zambotti, Galliker Dairy, Baseball
1999-J.J. Thomas, Seward VFW, Baseball
1998-Joe Sheridan, Bishop McCort, Football
1997-Jeremy Weber, Principle Development, Baseball
1996-John Tavares, Principle Development, Baseball
1995-Gino Betta, Sani-Dairy, Baseball
1994-no award
1993-Artrell Hawkins, Jr., Bishop McCort, Football
1992-Jeff Sotosky, Bishop McCort, Football
1991-Brian Mangiafico, Greater Johnstown, Football
1990-Greg Wilson, Bishop McCort, Football
1989-Steve Bellack, Bishop McCort, Football
1988-David Stremmel, Bishop McCort, Football and D.J. Getz, Coca-Cola, Baseball
1987-Bob Bulas, Bishop McCort, Football and Tom Walter, Pepsi-Cola, Baseball
1986-John Rok, Greater Johnstown, Football and Cary Grubb, Coca-Cola, Baseball
1985-Dale Lehman, Bishop McCort, football and Randy Mazey, Coca-Cola, baseball
1984-Donald Spaid, United, football and Brian Miller, Coca-Cola, baseball
1983-Derek Lawrence, Johnstown, football and Shawn Hillegas, Ramada Inn, baseball
1982-Bob Chunta, Forest Hills, football and Wayne Webb, Coca-Cola/Varsity Shop, baseball
1981-Dave Seidel, Bishop McCort, football and Craig Humbert, Coca-Cola, baseball
1980-Mike Burgo, Bishop McCort, football and Dave Andrews, Kiwanis, baseball
1979-Don Rector, Bishop McCort, football and Don Stanton, Jr., Ericksons, baseball
1978-Steve Katter, Bishop McCort, football and Ron Walling, Richland Mall, baseball
1977-no award
1976-Jim Livella, Bishop McCort, football and Ed Kozuch, Highland Boosters, baseball
1975-Ralph David, Blairsville, football and Terry Kosanovich, Highland Boosters, baseball
1974-Artrell Hawkins Sr., Johnstown, football and Michale Peel, Swanks Hardware, baseball
1973-Jack Buchan, Johnstown, football and Larry McCabe, Kline's Amusement, baseball
1972-John Sheehan, Bishop McCort, football and Pete Vuckovich, Monte Carlo, baseball
1971-Steve Topscher, Bishop McCort, football and Pete Vuckovich, Monte Carlo, baseball
1970-Jim Bradley, Bishop McCort, football and Gene Pentz, Monte Carlo, baseball
1969-Dennis Baltzer, Johnstown, football and Jim Burton, Detroit, baseball
1968-Ed Seman Jr., Johnstown football and James Gruca, Raymon's Club Grill, baseball
1967-Greg Campbell, Altoona, football and Barry Shellhammer, Monte Carlo, Baseball
1966-Joe McMillan, Johnstown, football and Fred Katawczik, Lower Cambria, baseball
1965-Joe McMillan, Johnstown, football and Tony Renzi, Lower Cambria, baseball
1964-Rick Britt, Johnstown, football and Paul Helsel, Hahn's Packing, baseball
1963-Ted Kurowski, Bishop McCort, football
1962-Don Havas, Bishop McCort, football
1961-Havert "Tojo" King, Johnstown, football
1960-Tom DeHart, Washington Boys Club, baseball
1959-John King, Johnstown, football
1958-George Azar, Johnstown, football
1957-Bill Faust, Johnstown, football
1956-Jim Janak, Bishop McCort, football
1955-Bill Spanko, Johnstown, football
1954-Bernie Grunza, Johnstown, football
1953-Bob Felton, 20th Ward AC, baseball
1952-Joe Burgo, Johnstown, football
1951-Angelo Certo, Bishop McCort, football
1950-Ray Gmuca, Johnstown, football
1949-Tommy Yewcic, Conemaugh, football
1948-Evan Slonac, Adams Township, football
1947-Paul Yewcic, Conemaugh, football
1946-Dave Coulson, Westmont, football
1945-Roger Bowman, Amsterdam, baseball
1944-Andy Havrylak, Central City, baseball
1943-Nunzio Marino, Windber, football
1942-Spiro Pappas, Johnstown, football
1941-John Makar, Johnstown, Football
1940-Charles Yarchak, Bishop McCort, Football
1939-Bob Longacre, Johnstown, Football
1938-Joe Wisor, Cochran, Football